There are many executive search firms on the market. Their websites say almost the same things: experience, network, tailored approach.
The difference only shows during the project. When the contract is signed and the time is already spent.
To choose well, ask the firm these 7 questions before you sign. The answers will show how the firm will really work.
In short: 7 questions
- Who will run my project ?
- What is your experience in my industry ?
- How do you find candidates ?
- How do you assess candidates ?
- How will you report on progress ?
- What is your guarantee ?
- Which companies will you not search in ?
Who will run my project ?
Often a partner signs the contract, and a junior person you have never met runs the search.
Ask directly: who will talk to candidates and who will represent your company on the market. Ask to meet this person before the project starts.
Good answer: one experienced consultant runs the project from the first meeting until the candidate starts.
What is your experience in my industry ?
A consultant who knows the industry understands your goal faster. They know the target companies, the language of the market and the usual career paths.
Ask for examples of similar projects: position, industry, difficulty. The firm may not name its clients, but it can explain what the project was.
Good answer: concrete examples of similar positions and a clear idea of where to search now.
How do you find candidates ?
There are two very different approaches:
- Database and job ads: the firm shows you people who are already looking for a job.
- Direct search: the firm builds a market map and approaches leaders who are not looking.
C-level and GM-1 positions need the second approach. The best candidates almost never reply to job ads.
Good answer: the firm explains how it builds the market map and is ready to show it to you.
How do you assess candidates ?
Anyone can send CVs. The value of a search firm is in the assessment: does the candidate really fit ?
Ask what the firm checks beyond experience:
- the candidate’s motivation;
- fit with the company culture and the owner;
- management style and risks under pressure;
- market reputation and references.
Good answer: a structured competency interview, a professional assessment tool (for example Hogan) and a written report on each finalist.
How will you report on progress ?
The most common client complaint: “We don’t know what is happening with our project.”
Agree in advance on:
- how often you will meet or receive a report;
- what the report contains: how many people were approached, how many are interested, why candidates decline;
- when you will see the first candidates.
Good answer: a regular report with numbers, and honest market feedback, even when it is not pleasant.
What is your guarantee ?
Even after a good hire, a leader can leave in the first months. You need to know in advance what happens then.
Check the guarantee period and what it covers. Serious firms run a new search free of charge.
Good answer: a clear period and a free replacement of the candidate, written in the contract.
Which companies will you not search in ?
This is a question of ethics, and clients rarely ask it. A serious firm does not take leaders from its own clients.
This also protects you: after the project, the firm will not search for candidates among your people.
Good answer: the firm raises the topic itself and explains its rules.
Warning signs
- The firm promises a shortlist within a few days, before studying the market.
- CVs are sent without the candidates’ agreement.
- The consultant asks no questions about the business, only about the job description.
- No clear answer on who will run the project.
- A fee far below the market: it usually means less time spent on your project.
How JFL Executive Search works
We hire C-level and GM-1 leaders for international and Russian companies in Moscow and all over Russia. One consultant runs your project from start to finish. We use direct search and Hogan assessment, and we give a guarantee with a free replacement of the candidate.
Positions: General Director, CFO, Commercial Director, Marketing Director, HR Director, Plant Director.

