logo
JFL Executive Search
Процесс найма CEO через рекрутинговую компанию

How to Hire an Executive Who Is Not Looking for a Job: 7 Rules of Direct Search

Table of Contents

The best leaders are almost never looking for a job.

They deliver good results, they are valued, and they do not browse job boards. Job ads mostly attract people who are available right now or unhappy in their current role.

This is why C-level and GM-1 positions need a different approach: direct search, or executive search.

In short: 7 rules of direct search

  1. Start with the business goal
  2. Build a market map
  3. Talk about a project, not a vacancy
  4. Be honest about the challenges
  5. Assess more than experience
  6. Keep the pace
  7. Prepare for the counteroffer

Start with the business goal, not the job description

A job description lists duties. A strong candidate wants to know something else: what must change in the company in the first 12-18 months.

  • Launch a new sales channel ?
  • Build the finance function from scratch ?
  • Bring the plant to full capacity ?

Key point: the clearer the goal, the more precise the search. And the easier it is to explain to the candidate why this role is worth a move.

Build a market map

Before calling candidates, you need to know where they work. A market map includes:

  • target companies in your industry;
  • neighbouring industries with similar experience;
  • people who changed jobs recently and are unlikely to move again;
  • people who may have a reason to consider a new project.

Key point: a market map often shows that there are fewer suitable candidates than expected. It is better to know this at the start than after three months.

Talk about a project, not a vacancy

A message saying “we have a vacancy” rarely works.

A strong leader wants to hear two things: why you contacted them personally, and what project you offer.

The first conversation must be personal and confidential. The candidate takes a risk with their reputation when agreeing to discuss a new position.

Key point: the candidate must be sure that nothing will leak to the market.

Be honest about the challenges

An experienced executive will find out the truth about the company anyway: through contacts, former employees, the market.

If you hide the problems, the candidate will drop out at the final meetings. Or worse, leave six months after joining.

Key point: being honest about the challenges attracts people who know how to solve them. For a strong leader, a difficult task is often the main motivation.

Assess more than experience

A CV shows what a person has done. But success in a new role depends on two more things:

  • Motivation: why they are ready to leave and what they really want.
  • Fit: whether their management style matches the company culture and the owner.

We use a structured competency interview and the Hogan personality assessment.

Key point: Hogan shows a leader’s strengths and the risks that appear under pressure.

Keep the pace

A strong candidate does not wait. If three weeks pass between meetings, they decide the company is not interested. Or they accept another offer.

What helps:

  • agree on the interview steps and participants in advance;
  • give feedback within a few days;
  • do not add new steps during the process;
  • define the salary range before the search starts.

Prepare for the counteroffer and support the transition

When a good leader resigns, the current employer almost always tries to keep them.

Discuss this scenario with the candidate early, before the offer.

The work does not end when the offer is accepted: notice period, first meetings with the team, the first 100 days.

Key point: the candidate needs support at every stage. This is why we support the leader during the first months in the job.

When to work with an executive search firm

You can run a direct search yourself. But a search firm gives a real advantage when:

  • the search must stay confidential, for example when replacing a current leader;
  • the profile is rare and there are few candidates on the market;
  • the HR team has no time for a long and complex project;
  • you need an independent view of the market and the candidates.

JFL Executive Search hires General Directors, CFOs, Commercial Directors, Marketing Directors, HR Directors and Plant Directors for international and Russian companies in Moscow and all over Russia.

Let’s discuss your project

You May Also Like

The executive search market in Russia changed more between 2022 and 2025 than in the twenty years before it. Global networks closed their Russian offices or sold them to their local teams. Those teams kept the people and the client base, but changed the name. So most of the lists you find online still send […]

There are many executive search firms on the market. Their websites say almost the same things: experience, network, tailored approach. The difference only shows during the project. When the contract is signed and the time is already spent. To choose well, ask the firm these 7 questions before you sign. The answers will show how […]